TidyShelf vs Gemini 2: finding duplicate files on Mac

Gemini 2 is a duplicate finder. TidyShelf finds duplicates and also helps you find, search and tidy all your files. How they compare on duplicates, features and pricing.

Search “find duplicate files mac” and Gemini 2 by MacPaw shows up near the top. It’s an app that does one thing: duplicates. TidyShelf finds duplicates too, as part of a bigger job: helping you find and tidy all your files. Here’s how they compare.

Details below were checked in November 2026; see MacPaw’s site for their latest plans.

Why people pick TidyShelf

  • Duplicates are rarely the only problem. TidyShelf also finds lost files, searches text inside screenshots and clears old downloads.
  • Duplicate folders, not just files. Spot the project you copied “just in case”.
  • One-time price. No yearly subscription.
  • Safe by design. Everything goes to the Trash, so you can undo.

What Gemini 2 is

Gemini 2 scans your Mac for duplicate and similar files and helps you remove them. It’s sold as a yearly subscription in the Mac App Store, with other options on MacPaw’s own store.

How TidyShelf handles duplicates

  • Exact duplicates by content. Files match even with different names in different folders.
  • Look-alike photos: bursts, edited copies and the same image saved at different sizes.
  • Duplicate folders, such as a project copied twice.
  • A suggested copy to keep, the space you’ll get back, and everything sent to the Trash.

Side by side

Gemini 2TidyShelf
Exact duplicate filesYesYes, by content
Similar photosYesYes
Search files by descriptionNoYes
Search text inside screenshotsNoYes, on your Mac
Clean up old installers and downloadsNoYes
Rename files from their contentsNoYes
PricingYearly subscription (App Store)One-time, free updates

How to find duplicate files on Mac

  1. Start with Photos. Open Photos and check Utilities › Duplicates to merge copies inside your library.
  2. Then scan Downloads with TidyShelf. It’s where most duplicate files live: the same PDF saved twice, files ending in “(1)”.
  3. Then Documents and Desktop. Look for copied folders and “final_v2” style versions.
  4. Review before removing. TidyShelf suggests the copy to keep, usually the one in the right folder rather than Downloads.
  5. Empty the Trash when you’re sure. Space is only freed then.

The bottom line

If you want duplicates gone and a tidier, searchable Mac, TidyShelf covers far more ground: duplicates and duplicate folders, search by description, text inside screenshots and Downloads cleanup, for one one-time price.

More guides

The Best File Organizer Apps for Mac in 2026: Which One Fits Your Workflow? →TidyShelf vs CleanMyMac: which Mac cleanup app do you actually need? →TidyShelf vs DaisyDisk: freeing up space on your Mac →